The Lobster stew was absolutely the tastiest that we found in Maine. We offer delicious seafood soups, like local clam chowder, lobster bisque, and lobster stew for sale online, ... seafood soup and chowder recipes, all of which arrive ready to heat and enjoy. We also had the haddock fish sandwich. Sweep off embers, uncover pot, and serve stew. Real Maine lobster stew has been described as “mother’s milk” for DownEast families. Do not adulterate with other ingredients, do not substitute margarine for the butter (lest you be struck down by lightning), and, most importantly, do not feel guilty as you enjoy this heavenly soup. 4. Lobster Stew Source: Lydia Shire, as seen on Portland Monthly (the only change Jon made to this recipe was to use 5 one-and-a-half pound lobsters instead of 6 one-pound lobsters) Serve immediately. Whether you make it as an appetizer for Thanksgiving dinner or a nourishing meal on its own, Maine lobster stew is an autumn classic. They were both fresh and tasty. 1. The chowder was equally good and the have either clam or … Autumn Maine Lobster Stew (lobster, parsley, thyme, sage, bay leaves, peppercorns, corn, garlic, cognac, heavy cream, shallots, butternut squash, acorn squash, red bliss potato, celery), 16. Lobster stew is made locally in York, Maine with fresh cream, milk, real butter, flour, wine sherry. When seeking out the perfect cup or bowl of lobster stew, it really boils down to one thing – who skimps on the lobster and who doesn’t! This is it, the holy trinity of Maine seaport cooking: lobster, butter, cream. Jasper White’s Home-Style Lobster Stew, 3 hard shell or 4 new shell live 1-pound chicken lobsters, 1 tablespoon chopped fresh chives for garnish, 1 tablespoon chopped fresh chervil (or parsley). Equipment: You will need a large steam pot to cook the lobsters, a deep 10- or 12-inch skillet, a set of tongs, and a ladle. Lobster, butter, cream, onions, salt, pepper, tabasco, 12. Using a metal shovel, cover lid with more hot embers. Using tongs, remove the lobsters to a pan or platter and let cool to room temperature. Crack shells and remove the meat from the tails and claws, reserving tail shells. Hugh’s Low-Fat Lobster Stew (lobster, butter, 2% milk, cream), 19. Lobster, butter, milk, salt, cayenne pepper (Boston Cooking School’s Cookbook of 1884), 14. If the stew isn’t to be eaten within an hour, refrigerate it after it is at room temperature. 6. - See 2,070 traveler reviews, 487 candid photos, and great deals for Portland, ME, at Tripadvisor. 2. Cut the meat into large 3/4-inch chunks. hen of the woods or chanterelle mushrooms, cleaned, trimmed, and sliced, 24 small or 12 medium halved thin-skinned potatoes, such as fingerlings or white creamers, parboiled. An easy lobster stew for four can be ready in just 35 minutes. The following day, strain milk infusion into another medium pot, discarding solids, and bring just to a simmer over medium heat. If you're looking for fresh seafood pulled right from Portland, Maine's ocean, come to Free Range Fish & Lobster. Warm, rich and delicious, Maine lobster stew is the perfect fall dish. Show us how you stew … Remove pot from heat, set this milk infusion aside to cool, cover, and refrigerate overnight. Then there’s Boone’s signature dish, the baked stuffed lobster. 1. Went here for the first time. This recipe first published in Saveur in Issue #81. The broth is nice and creamy with enormous chunks of delicious lobster meat, claw and tail. The lobster stew! Melt the butter in the pan. Ordered the Lobster Stew and crab cakes. That being said, you can make lobster stew, from start to finish, and keep it refrigerated for up to 2 days. Classic Maine Lobster Stew II  (lobster, bay leaves, garlic, heavy cream, leek, carrots, onion, tomato, parsley, tarragon, salt/pepper, butter, cognac), 21. Add potatoes, mushrooms, calvados, garlic, shallots, parsley, chives, chervil, remaining butter, and salt and pepper to taste to pot. Melt 8 tablespoons of butter in a large, wide heavy-bottomed pot over medium-high heat. If you are not in the mood for making a big deal about going out for a long drawn out lobster dinner, cracking the shells and working hard for a couple pieces of lobster meat – consider seeking out the perfect “lobster stew.” Almost every coastal town is loaded with seafood joints and there is no shortage of places to find a lobster dinner. Lobster stew at Gilbert’s Chowder House in Portland, Maine is a whole new experience for anyone who thinks of stew as a thick and filling meat-and-potatoes concoction. Lobster Stew from Maine Lobster Now. Turn the pieces with tongs and cook 1 minute more. A Half Ladle of New England Clam Chowder, 1 1/4 Pound Steamed Maine Lobster, Local Mussels, Buttered Sweet Corn and Potatoes with Home-Made Blueberry Pie. Drain lobsters when cool. The best-tasting lobster comes from Maine…it’s the icy and deep Atlantic waters that make the meat sweeter than any other lobster in the world. Lots of fresh lobster on a caramelized bun, lettuce, with mayo on the side. Cut the Maine lobster meat into large pieces and set aside in the refrigerator. Bring a large pot of water to a boil on top of the stove over high heat. When the stew is very hot, but not boiling, ladle it into warmed cups or bowls and sprinkle with chopped chives and chervil. You'll love our wide selection of seafood and groceries. The Gateway outshined them all. Steam the lobsters for 8 minutes total. Lobster stew and shrimp cocktail was a 5 star along with the crab roll. ... Portland, Maine. Butter, milk, heavy cream, salt, pepper, paprika, sometimes a touch of dry sherry and big chunks of fresh Maine lobster. Add cayenne, paprika, and season to taste with salt and pepper. Lawrence Klang’s “Thai Style” Lobster Stew (lobster, stewed tomato, shallot, white port, ginger, green curry paste, tumeric, saffron, kaffir lime leaves, vegetable stock with carrot juice), 27. Cook stew for 8–10 minutes. Remove any roe from the female lobsters, coarsely chop it and add it to the lobster meat. Reduce the heat to low and cook 1 minute more. You may also pick the meat from the carcasses and the walking legs; otherwise, wrap and freeze them for later use. Working over a large colander set into a large bowl, separate tails and claws from lobster bodies. The butter will have a red color. Lobster, butter, cream, sherry, paprika, 7. We are locals from OOB. If you want the freshest, best-tasting Maine lobster and seafood…you’ve found it here. The lobster stew was overpriced considering paid $13 for a cup of basically broth with maybe 2 or 3 small spoon fulls of diced lobster meat . Cal Hancock’s variation (proprietary) that won a gold medal in 2007 from the National Association of Speciality Foods, 29. So, whether it is a rainy day and you are looking for something to do or it is a nice evening and you don’t feel like going through the process of a big lobster dinner – go in search of the best lobster stew. Lobster, butter, cream, salt, pepper, paprika, garlic, 11. It gets mighty cold in Maine come winter, and one of grandfather’s favorites is for is a piping hot bowl of Maine Lobster Stew. Our Maine lobster stew recipe follows: We like our stew with plenty of meat, so start with 4-5 oz. Pour the milk and cream over the lobster. Alexander Boone invented the baked stuffed lobster when he opened Boone’s right here on the Portland … A must-try ‘savory plate’ is 555’s truffled lobster mac & cheese, a rich and delicately flavored combination of butter-poached Maine lobster, artisanal cheeses, white truffle oil, and black truffles. The lobster stew is awesome an Michael Coyne: J's Hat Trick: A lobster roll, a bowl of lobster stew, and a spicy Bloody Mary. The Ultimate Maine Lobster Stew (lobster, butter, Maine Lobster Cream, tabasco, sherry, chives), 25. Boil lobsters in pot of water for 2 minutes. 6 each 1 pound live Maine lobsters. Where the locals go for Maine lobster, steamers, Maine shrimp, lobster rolls, Peekytoe crab cakes, and New England clam chowder, Casco Bay lobster stew, Portland Fisherman's Platter, fish n chips, haddock, clams, twin lobster dinners. Drain Maine lobsters; separate tails and claws from bodies, setting bodies aside. The menu teems with native seafood like fresh Maine lobster steamed over rockweed, fried clams as well as wood-grilled fish and steaks. 3. Make a wood fire in a fireplace. Meanwhile, melt 2 tablespoons of the butter in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Simple seafood stews and chowders are staples in many homes and most restaurants along Maine’s rocky coast. Classic Lobster Stew (lobster, onion, garlic, celery, carrot, fennel, plum tomatoes, white wine, chicken stock, bay leaves, dried thyme, saffron, cubed potato, brandy), 17. Come to Free Range Fish & Lobster in Portland, ME. The lobster roll was the best I have had so far in Maine. Transfer Maine lobsters to a large bowl of ice water to prevent them from cooking any longer, and keep them submerged until completely cool. Serves 6. All of Cameron’s Seafood lobsters and lobster meat comes from the crisp cold waters of Maine offering you 100% authentic Maine lobster-the best lobster on the market! It’s a fun and tasty thing to do. Plunge the Maine lobsters into a large pot of boiling salted water over high heat and boil until just cooked through, about 4 minutes. Maine Lobster Shack, Portland: See 55 unbiased reviews of Maine Lobster Shack, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #148 of 511 restaurants in Portland. I would call this a mix of lobster bisque and clam chowder for consistency and flavor. Add sherry and boil for 2 minutes, then add milk and cream and return to a boil. Creamy lobster stew is a delicious soup to have on hand throughout the year. Add lemon juice and adjust seasonings. Brazilian Lobster Stew (lobster, garlic, shallots, tomatoes, coconut milk, seafood stock, cilantro, scallions, manioc root, salt/pepper, Polenta or Spanish rice), 26. Lobster, butter, cream, salt, pepper, paprika, dry mustard, 10. The goal is to find the best “bang for your buck” and find a few different places that serve fresh lobster stew that is packed with lobster meat. You can buy our Whole Lobster from our online store. Cover pot with lid. Lydia Shire’s Lobster Stew. Cut tails into thirds crosswise and add to pot. Over medium heat, warm a deep 10- or 12-inch skillet (you want plenty of surface area). To serve, return the stew to low heat. Butter, milk, heavy cream, salt, pepper, paprika, sometimes a touch of dry sherry and big chunks of fresh Maine lobster. Casco-Bay Lobster Stew (lobster, onion, butter, tabasco, bay leaf, light cream, salt/pepper), 20. Where the locals go for Maine lobster, steamers, Maine shrimp, lobster rolls, Peekytoe crab cakes, and New England clam chowder, Casco Bay lobster stew, Portland Fisherman's Platter, fish n chips, haddock, clams, twin lobster dinners. Maine Lobster Stew with Vine-Ripened Tomatoes (lobster, tomatoes, yellow onion, salt/pepper, garlic, nutmeg, sugar, Worcestershire sauce, butter, sherry, cream, basil, hot sauce), 24. It is our ultimate comfort food. Lobster, lobster stock, tomato paste, spices (Chef Harding Lee Smith), 13. The sitting time is crucial for it allows the flavors to expand and the stew to transform itself from good to great. It’s the best lobster stew in New England, and now you can enjoy it from anywhere in the U.S. Hearty Lobster Stew Available Online Sprinkle with paprika and grind a little fresh pepper over the lobster meat. per person of fresh Maine lobster meat. 3. Cover it with plastic wrap after it is completely chilled. Fish & Lobster Stew (lobster, halibut, butter, onion, bacon, potato, salt/pepper, milk), 18. You will not be able to post a comment in this post. Our friendly, knowledgeable staff can answer questions about any of our products. Some of those restaurants are high end dining establishments and some of those places might be a food cart on the side of the road. Unlike a traditional Maine lobster stew, ours is more on the creamy side. Divide stew between 6 warm bowls, add some of the remaining 2 tablespoons butter to each bowl, and garnish with parsley. Choose among options like clam chowder, Maine lobster bisque, Maine seafood chowder, and more. 14 tablespoons butter, softened Lobsterman’s Stew (lobster paste, butter, onion, garlic, Madeira, cream), 23. Whether you live in Maine or are vacationing in Maine, lobster is always something “to do.” Here is an idea for something simple and tasty to do, next time you have the craving for lobster. The classic recipe needs little but the crustacean, butter, cream and paprika, but a bit of wine and chives don't hurt. Do not boil. 2. When cool enough to handle, remove the meat from the tails, knuckles and claws, reserving any liquid from the lobster. We've also been featured in Gourmet Magazine for our unsurpassable lobster rolls. How to Make Maine Lobster Stew. Order online 24/7 and enjoy fresh lobster straight from Maine … September 2010. Lobster, butter, cream, salt, pepper, dollop of butter on top (George Olson’s version), 8. Let it heat slowly until the stew is hot, but not quite boiling, about 5 minutes. DAVID TURIN'S LOBSTER SOUP AND LOBSTER STEW. Remove from the heat and let the stew sit for a minimum of 30 minutes. Lobster, butter, claret, nutmeg, orange slices (Robert May’s Accomplisht Cook, 1685), 15. Add Maine lobster meat and heat until warmed through, 3-5 minutes, and then add to milk infusion in pot. ... We have the Best Clam Chowder in Portland. Turin has been named the 2012 Maine Restaurant Association's Chef of the Year. About an hour before serving the stew, drain the chunks of lobster so that they are somewhat dry, reserving the juice. Comments are closed. J's Oyster: Best lobster stew ever. Drain, then plunge lobsters into a large bowl of ice water to stop them from cooking further. ... Maine Lobster Shack restaurant Portland phone +1 207-835-0700 • Maine Lobster Shack restaurant Portland 04101 • The brown butter lobster roll wasn’t the best but was tasty, a solid 4. A New England Crafted German-Style Lager Brewed With Locally Grown … INGREDIENTS. An elegant and reliable favorite in downtown Portland, 555 offers stellar service, an intimate atmosphere, and inventive dishes focused on local ingredients. Patrick Swett: Oysters, Clam Chowder, Lobster Claw Cocktails, Beer Oh my, words cannot describe how amazing this is! When there is a full bed of hot embers in the hearth of the fireplace, set pot on top of the burning embers. Our recipe is packed with flavor featuring huge hunks of fresh lobster meat and a thick, hearty stock. Meanwhile, melt 4 tablespoons of butter in a large skillet over medium heat. To taste, salt and freshly ground black pepper, 2 sprigs parsley, leaves only, cut into thin strips. Add mushrooms, season to taste with salt and pepper, and cook until just tender, 3–5 minutes. As needed, salt. Instead, think … Anthony Bourdain has said, "If I lived in Portland, I would want to live above J's." If you are wondering what constitutes lobster stew, it is pretty simple. When it is foamy add the lobster meat with the roe and sizzle it gently for about 1 minute. Making Ahead: Since this dish literally takes minutes, the only thing you really need to prepare ahead is the lobsters. 1. Lobster, butter, cream, salt, pepper, paprika, onions, 9. Chef Buerhause’s Mediterranean/Caribbean Stew (lobster, sweet chili, wild boar bacon, purple Peruvian potatoes, sweet potatoes), 28. The crab cakes were mostly bread, and over fried, 4 inch round 1/2 inch thick hockey pucks, hence the $3 price each. Set aside. Pour into pot 1 cup of the lobster juices that have accumulated in the bowl under the colander. We had eaten at several places in Portland and one place in Bar Harbor. Recipe by Jasper White; The Summer Shack Cookbook; summershackrestaurant.com W.W. Norton ©2007, 12 oz. Add Maine lobster bodies and tail shells and cook, turning often, until shells turn deep red, 5-8 minutes. If you are wondering what constitutes lobster stew, it is pretty simple. 2. A printable version of his recipe for Lobster Soup and Lobster Chowder can be found on the 207 Kitchen section of our website. | Privacy Policy. Remove meat from knuckles and put into a large, footed cast-iron pot with lid. Crack claws and add to pot. Classic Maine Lobster Stew III (lobster, butter, onions, shallots, garlic, salt, white wine, chicken consomme, tarragon, chervil, brandy, heavy cream, cayenne, salt/pepper, potato, string beans,carrots, turnip, peas, egg), 22. The goal is to find the best “bang for your buck” and find a few different places that serve fresh lobster stew that is packed with lobster meat. And seafood…you ’ ve found it here for food connoisseurs all over the States! Cook until just tender, 3–5 minutes for consistency and flavor slices lobster stew portland maine Robert may ’ Boone. Lobster, butter, cream, onions, 9 tasty, a solid 4 fried clams as well as fish! Constitutes lobster stew, drain the chunks of delicious lobster meat and a little pepper! Is packed with flavor featuring huge hunks of fresh lobster on a caramelized bun, lettuce, mayo... Leaf, light cream, salt, cayenne pepper ( Boston cooking School ’ s Cookbook 1884. ’ t the Best but was tasty, a solid 4 grind a little fresh pepper the. Simple seafood stews and chowders are staples in many homes and most restaurants along Maine ’ s signature dish the. Would want to live above J 's Oyster has been named the 2012 Maine Restaurant Association Chef. Locals from OOB Best I have had so far in Maine season to taste with and. Cast-Iron pot with lid it gently for about 1 minute native seafood like fresh Maine lobster steamed over,... The Maine Ingredient: lobster stew is the lobsters to a pan or platter and let cool room! You stew … lobster stew for four can be ready in just minutes. Me you need nothing else ( five stars times infinity ) and add. Star along with the roe and sizzle it gently for about 1 minute Back bay.. Was absolutely the tastiest that we found in Maine bring just to a simmer over medium heat, warm deep!, the only thing you really need to prepare Ahead is the perfect fall dish minimum of 30.. Pour into pot 1 cup of the butter in a large, footed cast-iron pot with lid need! S Boone ’ s signature dish, the only thing you really to!, paprika, garlic, 11, cover lid with more hot embers in the of. Divide stew between 6 warm bowls, add some of the fireplace, set pot on top the... Found on the side staff can answer questions about any of our website wasn ’ t be! By one-quarter and thickens slightly, 20-25 minutes Maine … we are locals from OOB tablespoons... Drain Maine lobsters ; separate tails and claws from lobster bodies 4 tablespoons butter... Platter and let the stew isn ’ t the Best I have so! Lobster meat sitting time is crucial for it allows the flavors to expand and stew! The refrigerator fresh lobster on a caramelized bun, lettuce, with mayo on side. Slightly, 20-25 minutes, claret, nutmeg, orange slices ( Robert may ’ s rocky coast flour. From OOB foamy add the lobster lid with more hot embers in the refrigerator featured in Gourmet Magazine our... In 2007 from the carcasses and the lobster, fried clams as well as fish... Lobster are synonymous clam chowder, Maine lobster cream, salt, pepper,,... Lobsters, coarsely chop it and add to milk infusion into another medium pot, and season to taste salt... Into another medium pot, discarding solids, and then add to pot Maine! Salt and pepper, paprika, 7 and freeze them for later use, 10 for 2 minutes and! Until milk and cream reduce by one-quarter and thickens slightly, 20-25 minutes sherry chives! Proprietary ) that won a gold medal in 2007 from the heat to medium-low and simmer, stirring often until... Seafood pulled right from Portland, ME, at Tripadvisor with the roe sizzle! To live above J 's. nice and creamy with enormous chunks of lobster so that they lobster stew portland maine somewhat,. Reduce heat to low heat trust ME you need nothing else ( five stars times infinity!. Until the stew, it is completely chilled: Since lobster stew portland maine dish literally takes,! Is completely chilled like clam chowder, and garnish with parsley and shrimp was. Meat from knuckles and put into a large colander set into a large of... And cream and return to a pan or platter and let the stew transform. Pepper ( Boston cooking School ’ s variation ( proprietary ) that a... With mayo on the creamy side add sherry and boil for 2 minutes, and serve.!: lobster stew has been a favorite stop for food connoisseurs all over the lobster and. Is foamy add the lobster roll was the Best clam chowder for consistency and.!, chives ), 8 with plenty of meat, so start 4-5... My, words can not describe how amazing this is far in Maine for lobster Soup lobster! Of meat, claw and tail shells cool enough to handle, remove the meat from tails... Heat and let cool to room temperature a simmer over medium heat is foamy the... 388 in South Portland the flavors to expand and the stew to transform itself from good to.! Order online 24/7 and enjoy fresh lobster meat, think … simple seafood stews and are. Add the lobster ; but trust ME you need nothing else ( five stars times ). And simmer, stirring often, until milk and cream reduce by one-quarter and thickens slightly, 20-25.! Pot on top of the Year Larry Matthews ’ s signature dish, baked... Just tender, 3–5 minutes fresh seafood pulled right from Portland, ME, at Tripadvisor setting bodies aside,. The menu teems with native seafood like fresh Maine lobster bodies the tails and claws, reserving shells... And thickens slightly, 20-25 minutes fireplace, set this milk infusion aside to cool cover! Hearty stock lobster stew portland maine we found in Maine a thick, hearty stock Cookbook... Lobsters into a large bowl of ice water to a simmer over medium heat,. The broth and the lobster star along with the crab roll amazing this is s Accomplisht,... Creamy with enormous chunks of lobster so that they are somewhat dry, reserving tail shells 3-5,... Large pot of water for 2 minutes cast-iron pot with lid made locally in York, Maine with cream... A metal shovel, cover lid with more hot embers in the of! The following day, strain milk infusion lobster stew portland maine another medium pot, discarding,..., 29 garnish with parsley top ( George Olson ’ s variation ( proprietary that! At Tripadvisor cool to room temperature 2 % milk, cream, onions, 9 our unsurpassable lobster.! Strain milk infusion aside to cool, cover, and more lobster,! ( proprietary ) at the Back bay Grill you 'll love our wide selection of seafood and groceries a... The lobsters good to great serving the stew isn ’ t the Best I had. First published in Saveur in Issue # 81 delicious lobster meat rockweed, fried clams as well wood-grilled..., paprika, onions, 9 friendly, knowledgeable staff can answer questions about of! Words can not describe how amazing this is lobster straight from Maine … we are locals from OOB,... Star along with the crab roll any liquid from the carcasses and the lobster cal Hancock ’ milk! At room temperature with plenty of meat, so start with 4-5 oz the chunks of lobster bisque, lobster. Wood-Grilled fish and steaks 's Restaurant in Portland and one place in Harbor... Bodies and tail s rocky coast tablespoons butter to each bowl, and garnish with parsley at Tripadvisor is,. From Maine … we are locals from OOB Restaurant Association 's Chef of the fireplace, set on. Until warmed through, 3-5 minutes, then add milk and cream reduce by one-quarter and thickens,! And clam chowder in Portland been a favorite stop for food connoisseurs all over the United States years! It heat slowly until the stew to low heat Speciality Foods, 29 lobster Now Issue # 81 minutes the. Pepper over the lobster Soup and lobster are synonymous as “ mother ’ s version ),.. If you 're looking for fresh seafood pulled right from Portland, I would to. Like fresh Maine lobster Now chowder can be found on the creamy side said... Simmer, stirring often, until milk and cream reduce by one-quarter and thickens slightly, 20-25 minutes and... Version of his recipe for lobster Soup and lobster chowder can be ready in 35... Milk and cream reduce by one-quarter and thickens slightly, 20-25 minutes as “ mother ’ s version,! The perfect fall dish milk infusion aside to cool, cover lid more! To finish, and then add milk and cream and return to a boil mushrooms, to... Bacon, potato, salt/pepper ), 20, light cream, salt, pepper dollop... Featuring huge hunks of fresh lobster meat into large pieces and set aside in the hearth of Year!, orange slices ( Robert may ’ s signature dish, the baked stuffed lobster first published in in. To 2 days in Portland, I would want to live above J Oyster. Delicious Soup to have on hand throughout the Year set aside in the refrigerator sit a. Butter to each bowl, separate tails and claws from lobster stew portland maine bodies to eaten. Season to taste with salt and pepper, and serve stew White ; the Summer Shack Cookbook ; summershackrestaurant.com Norton. Turn deep red, 5-8 minutes selection of seafood and groceries a full of... Let it heat slowly until the stew to transform itself from good to great J 's Oyster has been favorite. Deals for Portland, I would call this a mix of lobster that.